Short answer

A dispatch service only works for a van that already has its own operating authority, so the choice is really your own MC plus a dispatcher versus a lease onto a carrier. In our example, a light cargo van on its own authority comes out ahead once it grosses about $806 a week. A van rated 10,001 pounds or more needs about $1,306, because its insurance minimum and its safety rules are both heavier. The label on your door frame tells you which van you have. Below are the example numbers, so you can swap in your own.

This guide is for cargo van and sprinter owners deciding how to work: under their own MC with a dispatcher booking the loads, or leased onto an expedited carrier. We already worked this comparison for box trucks. Vans change the answer in two ways. The revenue per week is usually smaller, so fixed costs weigh more. And a van can sit on either side of the 10,001 pound weight line, which changes how much insurance your own authority must carry.

Two Ways to Run a Van

Your own authority with a dispatcher. The MC number, the insurance filing and the paperwork are yours. A dispatcher looks for loads, talks to brokers, books the freight and sends you the rate confirmation. The fee is whatever your dispatch agreement says, either a share of each load or a flat weekly amount. A dispatcher does not lend you authority or insurance. Without your own MC, there is nothing for a dispatcher to book the van under.

A lease onto a carrier. The van runs under the carrier’s authority and insurance, and the carrier keeps part of what each load pays. Federal leasing rules in 49 CFR Part 376 cover this arrangement for any motor vehicle, a cargo van included. The lease must be in writing, and section 376.12 lists what it has to spell out, including how you are paid and what can be deducted.

Fuel, the van payment, tires and repairs are on you either way, unless your lease says otherwise. We leave them out of the math so the comparison stays on what actually differs.

Check Your Label Before You Price Anything

Cargo vans and sprinters straddle a federal line. Under 49 CFR 390.5, a vehicle used in interstate commerce to carry property counts as a commercial motor vehicle when its gross vehicle weight rating, or its gross vehicle weight, is 10,001 pounds or more. The rating is printed on the certification label that 49 CFR 567.4 requires on the driver’s door edge, the door latch post or the hinge pillar. Go by the label on your own van, not the model name.

Here is what the line changes when you run under your own authority:

Rated under 10,001 lbRated 10,001 lb or more
Federal liability minimum for your authority filing, general freight$300,000, 49 CFR 387.303(b)(1)(i), when every vehicle in the fleet is under 10,001 lb$750,000, 49 CFR 387.9 and 387.303(b)(2)(i)
Commercial motor vehicle under 390.5NoYes
Driver qualification file, hours of service and logs, annual inspection, daily vehicle inspection reportFor general freight, federal Parts 391, 395 and 396 do not reach itYes: Parts 391, 395, 396.17 and 396.11
CDLNo, unless it hauls placarded hazmatNo under 26,001 lb, unless placarded hazmat or 16 or more passengers, 49 CFR 383.5

Brokers can ask for more coverage than the federal minimum, so ask before you buy a policy. The heavier van also costs more in time: the logbook, the driver file and the yearly inspection are your job when the authority is yours. For the full list of what a van owner needs to get started, see our cargo van owner-operator requirements.

A lease does not make these rules go away. When the van is a commercial motor vehicle, the safety rules still apply to it and to you as the driver. What changes is who holds the authority and the insurance filing. The carrier also sets its own requirements before it signs a lease with you.

The Example Van and the Inputs

Every figure below is an example we picked to show the math. None of them is a market rate or a quote. Replace each one with the number from your own insurance quote, dispatch agreement and lease.

  • Weekly gross in a normal week: $2,600
  • Dispatch fee: 10% of gross
  • Factoring: 2% of gross
  • Insurance on your own authority: $170 a week for a van under 10,001 lb, $260 a week for a van rated 10,001 lb or more
  • Filings and registrations on your own authority: $20 a week. This covers items such as the $300 USDOT registration fee under 49 CFR 360.3 and the $55 a year Unified Carrier Registration fee for 0 to 2 vehicles under 49 CFR 367.50, spread over the year, plus a process agent
  • Carrier share under the lease: 30% of gross
  • Lease charge-backs: $45 a week, for example an occupational accident premium the lease bills back to you

A $2,600 Week for a Light Van

Weekly itemOwn authority + dispatcherLeased on
Gross$2,600$2,600
Dispatch fee (10%)$260None
Factoring (2%)$52None
Insurance$170Carrier’s policy
Filings$20None
Carrier share (30%)None$780
Charge-backsNone$45
You keep$2,098$1,775

In this week, the light van on its own authority keeps $323 more. For the heavier van, swap the $170 insurance line for $260 and it keeps $2,008, still $233 ahead of the lease.

The Breakeven Gross

The two sides cost you money in different ways. On your own authority, 12% of every dollar goes to the dispatcher and the factor, and then a fixed $190 a week (light van) or $280 a week (heavy van) goes out no matter what. On the lease, 30% of every dollar goes to the carrier, and the fixed part is only the $45 in charge-backs.

Each extra dollar of gross is worth 18 cents more on your own authority (30% minus 12%). That edge has to cover the extra fixed cost first:

  • Light van: ($190 minus $45) divided by 0.18 = about $806 a week
  • Heavy van: ($280 minus $45) divided by 0.18 = about $1,306 a week

Above the breakeven, your own authority keeps more. Below it, the lease does. A heavier van needs about $500 more gross every week just to reach the same point.

Weekly grossLight van, own authorityHeavy van, own authorityLeased on
$0 (van sits)−$190−$280−$45
$800$514$424$515
$1,500$1,130$1,040$1,005
$2,600$2,098$2,008$1,775

The $0 row is the one people skip. A week off for repairs costs the light van $190 and the heavy van $280 on their own authority, against $45 on the lease. The $800 row sits right on the light van’s breakeven, so a run of slow weeks wipes out the gap.

The Same Gross Does Not Mean the Same Freight

The math above uses one gross number for both sides. In real life the loads will differ. On your own authority you run what your dispatcher finds on load boards and through brokers, and you wait for payment unless you factor. On a lease you run what the carrier has, and 49 CFR 376.12(f) requires the carrier to pay you within 15 days after you turn in the delivery paperwork.

So compare the numbers you would actually get. To match a light van lease week of $1,775 in our example, your own authority needs about $2,233 gross with a dispatcher: $1,775 plus $190 in fixed costs, divided by 0.88. The heavy van needs about $2,335.

Clauses That Move the Lease Number

The carrier share is only the first line. Read these parts of the lease before you compare:

  • Pay terms. Under 376.12(d), the pay must be stated in the lease or an addendum you get before the first trip, as a percentage, a rate per mile or another method.
  • Who pays what. Section 376.12(e) makes the lease say who covers fuel, tolls, permits and similar costs. Any item the carrier pays comes off your side of the table.
  • Charge-backs. Section 376.12(h) requires a list of every charge-back and how each is calculated. Add them all to the lease column.
  • Escrow. If the carrier holds an escrow, 376.12(k) requires the lease to state the amount, what it can be used for and how it is accounted for. Escrow is your money held back, so plan for it in your cash.
  • Forced purchases. Under 376.12(i), the lease cannot require you to buy or rent products, equipment or services from the carrier as a condition of the lease.

Put your own numbers in for every input above, then work out the breakeven with your real fixed costs. If your average week sits close to it, plan around your slow weeks, not your best ones.

Want to See What a Carrier Would Offer?

Apply for free with your van details. No MC number is required to apply, and we’ll share your information with carriers that may match your equipment and qualifications.

Find Cargo Van Opportunities → Find Sprinter Van Opportunities →

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a dispatch service book loads for my van without my own MC?

No. A dispatcher books freight for a van that already has its own operating authority and insurance on file. Without your own MC, the other route is to lease onto a carrier and run under its authority.

How much insurance does a cargo van need on its own authority?

For general freight, the federal minimum filed with your authority is $300,000 when every vehicle in your fleet is rated under 10,001 pounds, under 49 CFR 387.303(b)(1)(i). A van rated 10,001 pounds or more needs $750,000 under 49 CFR 387.9. Brokers can ask for more.

Does a sprinter van need a CDL?

Not for general freight. Under 49 CFR 383.5, a single vehicle needs a CDL when it is rated 26,001 pounds or more, carries 16 or more passengers, or hauls placarded hazardous materials. A sprinter rated 10,001 pounds or more is still a commercial motor vehicle, so the federal driver file, hours of service and inspection rules apply to it.

How do I find cargo van or sprinter opportunities through Expedited Jobs?

Apply for free with your van details. No MC number is required to apply, and your information is shared with carriers that may match your equipment and qualifications.